Agree & Join LinkedIn

By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.

Skip to main content
LinkedIn
  • Articles
  • People
  • Learning
  • Jobs
  • Games
Join now Sign in
Last updated on Feb 13, 2025
  1. All
  2. HR Management
  3. Career Counseling

You're receiving conflicting advice from career experts. How do you create the best plan for your client?

Receiving mixed guidance from career experts can be confusing, but you can still craft a solid plan for your client. Here's how to make sense of varied opinions:

  • Evaluate the source: Consider the credibility and experience of each expert to determine whose advice holds more weight.

  • Align with client goals: Match the advice with your client's career aspirations and personal values to ensure relevance.

  • Create a hybrid approach: Combine the most practical elements from different pieces of advice for a balanced strategy.

How do you handle conflicting career advice? Share your strategies.

Career Counseling Career Counseling

Career Counseling

+ Follow
Last updated on Feb 13, 2025
  1. All
  2. HR Management
  3. Career Counseling

You're receiving conflicting advice from career experts. How do you create the best plan for your client?

Receiving mixed guidance from career experts can be confusing, but you can still craft a solid plan for your client. Here's how to make sense of varied opinions:

  • Evaluate the source: Consider the credibility and experience of each expert to determine whose advice holds more weight.

  • Align with client goals: Match the advice with your client's career aspirations and personal values to ensure relevance.

  • Create a hybrid approach: Combine the most practical elements from different pieces of advice for a balanced strategy.

How do you handle conflicting career advice? Share your strategies.

Add your perspective
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
15 answers
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Pankaj Subedi

    Motivational Speaker | Inspiring Change & Empowering Minds to Achieve Their Potential | Let's Connect | Accepting Request | Linkedin Speaker

    • Report contribution

    To craft an optimal career plan for your client amidst conflicting advice, adopt a judicious approach that blends discernment with flexibility. Begin by rigorously assessing their core competencies, aspirations, and values. Sift through the discordant advice, evaluating the validity of each perspective based on empirical evidence and the client's unique context. Synthesize the best strategies, integrating a mix of pragmatism and innovation. Foster open dialogue with your client, ensuring their autonomy is respected while subtly guiding them toward the most congruent path. Thus, you fashion a personalized, resilient roadmap that balances opportunity with caution.

    Like
    4
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Aditya Sugiarto

    Management Student at Soegijapranata Catholic University|Head of Soegijapranata University Echo Life SCU Student Activity Unit|Environmental Activist|Human Resource Management (HRM)|Human Resource (HR) Enthusiast

    • Report contribution

    faced with diverse advice from career experts, creating the best career plan for a client requires a deep understanding of the value of human capital. in the long run, effective career counseling should take into account an individual's potential and aspirations. by integrating this knowledge, we can develop appropriate strategies to help clients achieve their career goals in a sustainable manner. this requires a holistic approach that takes into account the client's personal and professional needs. by doing so, clients can achieve more stable and satisfying career success.

    Like
    2
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Cheryl Van Dyke

    Distinguished Fellow Coach with BetterUp; Therapist with MDLive and Spring Health

    (edited)
    • Report contribution

    There's no such thing as career experts nor should they be giving advice. The only expert in a person's life is that person themself. This is what makes AI so faulty. It wants to give advice instead of asking questions of curiosity and interest.

    Like
    1
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Wassf A.

    Area Spa`s Manager / Spa & Recreations | Spa Management, Hospitality Industry

    • Report contribution

    When dealing with conflicting career advice, the key is to focus on what’s best for your client. First, evaluate the source of the advice, considering each expert's experience and expertise. Then, align the advice with your client’s goals, values, and aspirations to ensure it fits their unique needs. A hybrid approach works well by combining useful aspects of different perspectives to create a comprehensive strategy. This way, you provide a tailored plan that addresses both immediate needs and long-term objectives. It’s all about creating a flexible, client-centered approach.

    Like
    1
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Orin Kaniel

    I connect startups to top talent | HR & LinkedIn Consultant | Headhunter | Career Mentor | Interview Expert | Body Language Trainer | Goal-Digger | Founder of WORK IT ⭐

    • Report contribution

    When receiving conflicting advice from career experts, focus on your client's unique needs and goals. Analyze the common themes, validate insights with market trends, and prioritize strategies that align with their strengths. Test and refine the plan based on real-world feedback to ensure the best results.

    Like
    1
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Priya Narang Nagpal

    Driving 93% Career success through Soft Skills Training | Career Coach & Corporate Trainer | Resume Writer | Communication Coach | Interview Preparation, LinkedIn Optimization, SOPs/LORs | Soft Skillls Trainer

    • Report contribution

    Conflicting career advice is common, but clarity is key. Here's how I create the best plan for my client: I assess each expert's credibility, experience, and relevance to the client's field. I prioritize advice that aligns with the client's values, goals, and unique situation. I prioritize advice backed by data, research, or proven results. I actively involve the client in the decision-making process, empowering them to choose. I emphasize that career plans are dynamic and may need adjustments. I focus on advice that supports the client's long-term career aspirations. It's about filtering information, prioritizing the client's needs, and creating a personalized, effective plan.

    Like
    1
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Neetha Rajan

    Senior HR Professional | Expert in Employee Relations, Workforce Strategy & Leadership Development

    • Report contribution

    When advice clashes, I don’t choose sides—I filter through the client's lens. I map each perspective against the client’s goals, values, and context. Instead of chasing the “right” advice, I look for patterns, not prescriptions—what themes repeat, and where do they diverge? Then, I involve the client as a co-creator, crafting a bespoke strategy that blends insight with intuition. The best plan isn’t the loudest opinion—it’s the one that fits their path with clarity and conviction.

    Like
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Nataliia Brytska🧸🎁📚

    Business woman children's toys store🚗🇺🇸

    • Report contribution

    When receiving conflicting advice from career experts, it’s important to approach the situation with a balance of openness and critical thinking.

    Like
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Owais Baig

    HR Manager @ Young's | Strategic Partner, Positive Work Culture

    • Report contribution

    When receiving conflicting advice from career experts, I focus on tailoring the best plan to my client’s unique goals and circumstances. I analyze the different perspectives, identifying common themes and weighing their practicality. Understanding my client’s strengths, industry trends, and long-term aspirations helps me filter out what aligns best with their needs. I also encourage flexibility, allowing for adjustments as they progress. By combining expert insights with my client’s personal vision, I craft a strategic, adaptable plan that supports their career growth effectively.

    Like
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Jess Taylor

    Co-Founder at Innovatum & Diversity in Tech Specialist🚀🦀

    • Report contribution

    Getting mixed advice from career experts can feel like trying to follow five GPS directions at once. But honestly, it’s a great chance to sharpen your own game and build a plan that actually works for your client. First things first—check the source. Who’s been in the trenches and who’s just repeating buzzwords? Not all advice is created equal. Then, filter everything through what really matters: your client’s goals, values, and the life they’re trying to build. What sounds good on paper might not fit their version of success. There’s no rule saying you have to pick just one piece of advice. Mix and match the best parts, scrap the rest, and create a game plan that’s realistic, personalized, and keeps your client moving forward.

    Like
View more answers
Career Counseling Career Counseling

Career Counseling

+ Follow

Rate this article

We created this article with the help of AI. What do you think of it?
It’s great It’s not so great

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.

Tell us more

Report this article

More articles on Career Counseling

No more previous content
  • Your client's personal struggles are hindering your counseling. How can you establish effective boundaries?

  • The job market is highly competitive. How do you keep your clients motivated?

  • You're at odds with your boss over a client's job fit. How do you handle the situation diplomatically?

  • Your client faces microaggressions during career planning. How can you support and empower them?

  • Your client is resistant to exploring new career paths. How do you support them effectively?

  • Your client's lack of progress is draining your motivation. How can you regain your drive and well-being?

  • Your client is struggling with imposter syndrome. How can you guide them towards their dream job success?

No more next content
See all

More relevant reading

  • Communication
    Here's how you can effectively convey a career change to potential employers.
  • Job Search Strategies
    Here's how you can navigate your career change conversation with potential employers.
  • Career Management
    Here's how you can make strategic career decisions with ease.
  • Career Development
    Here's how you can maintain focus and clarity in your career decision-making.

Explore Other Skills

  • Training and Development (HR)
  • Human Resources (HR)
  • Training
  • HR Consulting
  • Career Development Coaching
  • Career Development
  • HR Operations
  • Resume Writing
  • Recruiting
  • Global Talent Acquisition

Are you sure you want to delete your contribution?

Are you sure you want to delete your reply?

  • LinkedIn © 2025
  • About
  • Accessibility
  • User Agreement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Copyright Policy
  • Brand Policy
  • Guest Controls
  • Community Guidelines
Like
1
15 Contributions